[XviD-devel] One clip with Bframes, quality vs size

Christoph Lampert xvid-devel@xvid.org
Sun, 18 Aug 2002 17:33:47 +0200 (CEST)


  This message is in MIME format.  The first part should be readable text,
  while the remaining parts are likely unreadable without MIME-aware tools.
  Send mail to mime@docserver.cac.washington.edu for more info.

---595374472-545546416-1029684827=:15514
Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII

Hi,

we got the rewritten ME running for Bframes and I attached a typical
graph:  It's the average bpp (logarithmic) versus average PSNR
for all combinations of 

fixed quant = 2,3,4,5,6
max_bframes = 0,1,2,3
bquant_ratio = 80,100,150,200,250 

and last red dot: fixed-quant 7, max_b=0

The colors correspond to max_bframes, 
red is 0, green is 1, blue is 2, purple is 3. 

It's obvious that for this clip, no encoding include B-frames can beat
non-bframes (red line), no matter how hard they try...

Christoph 

-- 
Christoph H. Lampert chl@math,uni-bonn,de | Diese Signature wurde maschi-     
Beringstr. 6, Raum 14 Tel. (0228) 73-2948 | nell erstellt und bedarf
Sprechstunden: keine, aber meistens da    | keiner Unterschrift. AZ 27B-6 

---595374472-545546416-1029684827=:15514
Content-Type: APPLICATION/x-chess-pgn; name="Bframes-quality-vs-size.pgn"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: BASE64
Content-ID: <Pine.LNX.4.21.0208181733470.15514@lieb.math.uni-bonn.de>
Content-Description: 
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="Bframes-quality-vs-size.pgn"
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---595374472-545546416-1029684827=:15514--